Hanoi-Vietnam: Guidelines on scoring for assessing agricultural cooperatives

No.

Criterion name

Details of assessment

Assessment criteria

Maximum Scale

Scoring

1

Revenue and results of production and business activities in the year of the cooperative

Realized revenue / planned revenue ratio

8

- Less than 100%: 0 points

- From 100% to less than 120%: 4 points

- From 120% or more: 8 points

Total annual revenue of the cooperative

10

- Less than 1 billion VND/year: 4 points

- From 1 billion VND to less than 5 billion VND/year: 6 points

- From 5 billion VND to less than 10 billion VND/year: 8 points

- From 10 billion VND/year or more: 10 points

Income after fulfillment of financial obligations per member of the cooperative (Annual income after fulfillment of financial obligations/member)

10

- No profit after tax: 0 points

- Profitable, average less than 1 million VND/person: 2 points

- Profitable, average 1 to less than 5 million VND/person: 4 points

- Profitable, average 5 to less than 10 million VND/person: 7 points

- Profitable, average 10 million VND/person or more: 10 points

Deduction from the development investment fund shall not be less than 20% of the income

5

- Do not set aside or set aside less than 20% of income: 0 points

- Deduction from the development fund not less than 20% of income: 5 points

Deduction from the financial reserve fund is not less than 5% of income

5

- Do not set aside or set aside funds lower than 5% of income: 0 points

- Appropriation for fund not less than 5% of income: 5 points

2

Benefits of cooperative members

Prioritize service rates for members over non-member customers

8

- No priority service price for members: 0 points

- Have priority service price for members (or cooperatives that only provide services to members): 8 points

Prioritize income distribution to members according to the level of use of products and services of the cooperative (or the labor effort contributed by members to the cooperative to create jobs)

8

- The remaining income after setting up funds that are not distributed or distributed to members is less than 50% according to the level of use of products and services (or the member's labor contribution): 0 points

- The remaining income after setting up funds distributed to members is 50% or more according to the level of use of products and services (or the member's labor contribution): 8 points

3

Operating capital of cooperatives

Rate of increase in contributed capital and mobilization from cooperative members (%) = (contributed and mobilized capital from TV this year – contributed capital and mobilized from TV in the previous year)/ contributed capital and mobilized from TV in the previous year (in case there is no contribution in the previous year, this year there is contribution and mobilization, the rate is 100%)

7

- Decrease or no increase in equity: 0 points

- Less than 20%: 3 points

- From 20% to 50%: 5 points

- From 50% and above: 7 points

Operating capital of cooperatives (including all contributed capital of members, mobilized capital, accumulated capital, funds of the cooperative; subsidies and supports of the State, domestic and foreign organizations and individuals; donations, donations and other lawful revenue sources)

10

Less than 500 million VND: 1 point

From 500 million to less than 1 billion VND: 5 points

From 1 billion to less than 10 billion VND: 7 points

From 10 billion VND or more: 10 points

4

Cooperative membership size positively affects the community

Cooperative membership size positively affects the community

8

- Cooperatives with less than 30 members: 2 points

- Cooperatives with between 30 and less than 100 members: 4 points

- Cooperatives with from 100 members to less than 500 members: 6 points

- Cooperatives with more than 500 members: 8 points

5

Cooperatives to be rewarded in the year

Cooperatives to be rewarded in the year

6

- Cooperatives that are not rewarded in the year: 0 points

- Cooperatives awarded by the district level in the year: 3 points

- Cooperatives that are commended or rewarded at the provincial level or higher in the year: 6 points

6

Members' satisfaction with the cooperative

Members' satisfaction with the cooperative

15

Transfer the average aggregate score/valid vote of cooperative members participating in the assessment of the satisfaction level of cooperative members into the cooperative's self-scoring table

Overall Score

100