Based on Article 2 of Joint Circular 10/2013/TTLT-BTP-BCA-TANDTC-VKSNDTC-BTC guiding the Criminal Code 1999 on the crime of illegal printing, issuing, and trading of invoices, documents for collecting and paying into the state budget. The actions identified as illegal invoice trading include:
- Trading export invoices used in business activities involving exporting goods and services abroad, exporting into non-tariff zones;
- Trading value-added tax invoices (trading red invoices);
- Trading invoices for domestic goods and services sales intended for organizations and individuals declaring value-added tax;
- Trading other invoices including: stamps, tickets, cards, insurance collection receipts, etc., and air freight collection receipts.
The entities identified as committing this crime include:
- Individuals selling goods, providing services, or representatives of business organizations selling goods, providing services;
- Representatives of the organization that receive or place orders for printing invoices;
- Individuals or representatives of organizations purchasing goods, services.
It is acknowledged that according to the current regulations (Article 203 of the Criminal Code of Vietnam 2015, amended and supplemented 2017) the highest penalty frame for the crime of illegal invoice trading is a fine ranging from 200 to 500 million VND or imprisonment from 1 to 5 years in cases such as having an organization, abusing power, dangerous recidivism, etc.
Below is a collection of judgments regarding illegal invoice trading prosecuted by courts in Vietnam:
No. |
Name of Judgement |
Date of issue | Judicatory Body |
1 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading No. 84/2024/HS-ST |
31/01/2024 | People’s Court of Tu Son City, Bac Ninh Province |
2 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents No. 26/2023/HS-PT |
12/01/2023 | High People's Court in Hanoi |
3 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents, and Usurious Lending in Civil Transactions No. 426/2023/HS-PT |
14/06/2023 | High People's Court in Hanoi |
4 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading No. 16/2022/HS-ST |
06/04/2022 | People's Court of Hong Bang District, Hai Phong City |
5 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading No. 22/2022/HS-ST |
12/5/2022 | People's Court of Ha Nam Province |
6 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading No. 67/2022/HS-ST |
08/07/2022 | People's Court of Lao Cai City, Lao Cai Province |
7 |
Judgment No. 22/2021/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading |
08/03/2021 | People's Court of Bac Kan City, Bac Kan Province |
8 |
Judgment No. 62/2021/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents |
28/04/2021 | People's Court of Ngo Quyen District, Hai Phong City |
9 |
Judgment No. 28/2020/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading |
20/05/2020 | People's Court of Ngo Quyen District, Hai Phong City |
10 |
Judgment No. 236/2020/HS-PT on Illegal Printing, Trading Invoices |
19/05/2020 | People's Court of Ho Chi Minh City |
11 |
Judgment No. 27/2020/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading |
11/03/2020 | People's Court of District L, Hanoi City |
12 |
Judgment No. 07/2019/HS-PT on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents |
13/03/2019 | People's Court of Phu Yen Province |
13 |
Judgment No. 46/2019/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading |
15/08/2019 | People's Court of Dien Bien Province |
14 |
Judgment No. 61/2019/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents |
01/08/2019 | People's Court of District S, Da Nang City |
15 |
Judgment No. 97/2019/HS-ST on Illegal Invoice Trading và trốn thuế |
14/08/2019 | People's Court of Yen Phong District, Bac Ninh Province |
16 |
Judgment No. 621/2019/HS-PT on Illegal Invoice Trading |
15/10/2019 | High People's Court in Hanoi |
17 |
Judgment No. 111/2019/HS-PT on Illegal Invoice Trading, chứng từ thu nộp ngân sách nhà nước |
28/02/2019 | People's Court of Ho Chi Minh City |
18 |
Judgment No. 18/2018/HS-PT on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents |
20/03/2018 | People's Court of Lam Dong Province |
19 |
Judgment on Illegal Invoice Trading, State Budget Collection and Payment Documents No. 48/2018/HS-PT |
27/04/2018 | People's Court of Quang Ngai Province |
20 |
Judgment No. 71/2017/HS-PT on Illegal Invoice Trading |
27/09/2017 | People's Court of Hai Phong City |
Please Login to be able to download